Dead Island 2: Creature Comforts Walkthrough – How to Get the Peggy Rifle

In the sun-drenched ruins of HELL-A, survival isn't just about staying alive—it's about staying civilized. The Creature Comforts side quest is one of the most rewarding missions in the early-to-mid game of Dead Island 2. Not only does it flesh out the eccentric character of aging Hollywood star Curtis Sinclair, but it also rewards you with "Peggy," a high-powered hunting rifle that remains a top-tier choice for long-range zombie disposal.

This guide will walk you through the mansions of Bel-Air to secure Curtis’s requested luxuries: vintage whiskey, fine wine, and premium cigars.

Quest Overview

After clearing the initial main story beats and helping Curtis Sinclair at his mansion, you can return to him to trigger this quest. Curtis is looking to ride out the apocalypse in style, and he needs you to scavenge specific items from the neighboring luxury estates.

Phase 1: The Ardkillin Whiskey

The hunt begins in the luxury courtyard of Colt Swanson’s estate. This isn't a simple loot run; you’ll face an intense combat encounter starting at [0:00:00].

• The Target: Look for "Colt’s Gal Cindy," a specialized zombie holding the key you need.
• The Strategy: Use heavy blunt weapons to manage the crowd of walkers and runners. Once Cindy is down, retrieve the safe key from her remains at [0:02:15].
• The Loot: Head into the master closet upstairs to find the bedroom safe. Cracking it open rewards you with the vintage Ardkillin Whiskey.

Phase 2: Infiltrating the GOAT Pen

The mission then takes you toward the infamous GOAT Pen, a sprawling influencer mansion.

• Environmental Combat: At [0:04:30], the walkthrough demonstrates how to use the environment to your advantage. By utilizing an electrified swimming pool, you can lure large groups of undead into the water for a high-efficiency "shock and awe" strategy.
• The Maison Sang-Vivant: Finding the wine requires a trip to the wine cellar at [0:06:45]. Be prepared for a claustrophobic brawl. The tight corners of the wine room make it easy to get swarmed, so keep your guard up.

Phase 3: The Screamer and the Living Room Skirmish

Retrieving the goods triggers a massive combat event in the GOAT Pen’s open-concept living area at [0:09:00].

• Managing the Screamer: A Screamer will attempt to buff the surrounding shamblers. This guide showcases using Fury Mode and electric melee strikes to disrupt her sonic attacks and clear the room quickly.
• The Final Item: After the room is clear, head to the master suite at [0:11:15] to find the box of premium Cuban cigars sitting on the closet shelves.

The Reward: Peggy

Once you have the whiskey, wine, and cigars, head back to Curtis Sinclair’s residence at [0:13:30]. After a brief exchange, he will hand over his prized possession: Peggy.

Why Peggy is Essential:

• High Stopping Power: Peggy is a Superior-tier hunting rifle that deals massive physical damage.
• Precision Tool: It is perfect for taking out high-threat targets like Screamers or Slobbers from a safe distance before they can trigger their abilities.
• Scaling: Peggy scales exceptionally well with upgrades, making it a reliable primary weapon for a significant portion of the late game.

Key Highlights & Tips

• Check the Safes: Many of the quest items are locked behind named zombies. If a door or safe is locked, look for a zombie with a unique name nearby.
• Hazard Management: Use the water cans and exposed wires found throughout the GOAT Pen. This mission is a great opportunity to practice "elemental" combat to save on weapon durability.
• Don't Rush: The GOAT Pen is filled with traps and hidden loot. Take the time to explore the bedrooms while looking for the cigars to find extra crafting materials.

For a full interactive breakdown and clickable timestamps, visit the PixelFun Gaming Walkthrough.